โ† All Stories
Album release
Horses by Patti Smith album cover

ON THIS DAY IN 1975 - A FIGHT WITH HER SISTER BECAME A SONG ABOUT A WOMAN FOUND DEAD ON A BEACH

ON THIS DAY IN 1975 โ€” A FIGHT WITH HER SISTER BECAME A SONG ABOUT A WOMAN FOUND DEAD ON A BEACH โšก
Share this story
Facebook X WhatsApp

ON THIS DAY IN 1975 โ€” A FIGHT WITH HER SISTER BECAME A SONG ABOUT A WOMAN FOUND DEAD ON A BEACH โšก

Four years before Patti Smith released *Horses*, a rare argument with her sister Linda sent her imagination somewhere terrifying.

In 1971, Smith was sharing a space near New Yorkโ€™s Chelsea Hotel with Linda and Robert Mapplethorpe. One afternoon, the sisters quarreled and Linda left. When she still had not returned by nightfall, Smith became frightened that something might have happened to her. ๐ŸŒ™

Needing time to think, Smith took the F train to Coney Island. She sat on the beach until sunrise, surrounded by the dark ocean and the remains of the day. ๐Ÿš‡๐ŸŒŠ

After returning, she wrote the draft that would become โ€œRedondo Beach.โ€ Her real anxiety was transformed into fiction: a narrator searches for a missing woman, only to discover that a woman has been found dead near the ocean. The fear of losing a sister had become a stark story of absence, grief and irreversible loss. โœ๏ธ

When Smith awoke, Linda had returned safely. Smith showed her what she had written and later recalled that the two sisters never fought again.

The text eventually became one of the defining songs on *Horses*, set against a reggae-influenced arrangement created with Lenny Kaye and Richard Sohl. ๐ŸŽธ Its gently swaying music makes the narrative feel even more unsettlingโ€”the sound moves lightly while the story grows increasingly bleak.

That contrast gives โ€œRedondo Beachโ€ its lasting power. It began with an ordinary family argument, passed through one frightened night, and emerged as something haunting enough to live far beyond it. ๐Ÿ–ค

#PattiSmith #Horses #RedondoBeach #OnThisDay #RockHistory #PunkPoetry #musicOnOff

Horses cover
Listen & discover moreHorsesPatti Smith ยท 1975 ยท Punk RockOpen in Albums Gallery โ†’

๐Ÿ› Shop Music

Vinyl, CDs, merch, T-shirts and hoodies from across musicOnOff
Amazon
New Skin For The Old Ceremony CD Leonard Cohen New Skin For The Old Ceremony Amazon โ†— Oasis Definitely Maybe T-Shirt Hoodie Oasis Oasis Definitely Maybe T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Like a Virgin - Exclusive Limited Edition Vinyl Madonna Like a Virgin - Exclusive Limited Edition Amazon โ†— Love Zeppelin Proud Name Personalized Lovers Apparel Airship T-Shirt T-Shirt Love Zeppelin Proud Love Zeppelin Proud Name Personalized Lovers Apparel Airship T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Nirvana - In Utero Tour Merch Nirvana Nirvana - In Utero Tour Amazon โ†— inspiral carpets moo! T-Shirt T-Shirt Inspiral Carpets inspiral carpets moo! T-Shirt Amazon โ†— FEA Men's Tool Spectre Spiral Vicarious Men's T-Shirt T-Shirt Tool FEA Men's Tool Spectre Spiral Vicarious Men's T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Sinead O'Connor Cover T Shirt Rememberings Vinyl Album About Nothing Shirt for Men T-Shirt Sinead O'Connor Sinead O'Connor Cover T Shirt Rememberings Vinyl Album About Nothing Shirt for Men Amazon โ†— If You Can Believe Your Eyes And Ears CD The Mamas & The Papas If You Can Believe Your Eyes And Ears Amazon โ†— Blondie Men's Staredown Slim Fit T-Shirt Medium White T-Shirt Blondie Blondie Men's Staredown Slim Fit T-Shirt Medium White Amazon โ†— The Beatles Rubber Soul T-Shirt T-Shirt The Beatles The Beatles Rubber Soul T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Cream Men's Disraeli Gears T-shirt T-Shirt Cream Cream Men's Disraeli Gears T-shirt Amazon โ†— Alice in Chains T Shirt Self Titled Album T-Shirt Alice In Chains Alice in Chains T Shirt Self Titled Album Amazon โ†— Ramones Presidential Seal T-Shirt T-Shirt Ramones Ramones Presidential Seal T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Foot Traffic Men's Music-Themed Socks, Guitar Neck Merch Foot Traffic Men's Foot Traffic Men's Music-Themed Socks, Guitar Neck Amazon โ†— Hippie shirt Hippie symbol print on pocket t shirt gift idea T-Shirt T-Shirt Hippie shirt Hippie Hippie shirt Hippie symbol print on pocket t shirt gift idea T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Hesitation Marks Vinyl Nine Inch Nails Hesitation Marks Amazon โ†— Rush A Farewell to Kings Retro Band T-Shirt Black T-Shirt Rush Rush A Farewell to Kings Retro Band T-Shirt Black Amazon โ†— Yes - Classic Logo T-Shirt T-Shirt Yes Yes - Classic Logo T-Shirt Amazon โ†— American Classics Duran Duran T-Shirt T-Shirt Duran Duran American Classics Duran Duran T-Shirt Amazon โ†— The bauhausART Logo - 100th Anniversary of the Design School T-Shirt T-Shirt The bauhausART Logo The bauhausART Logo - 100th Anniversary of the Design School T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Guns N' Roses VKEGNIO Roses Tank Top Women T-Shirt Guns N' Roses Guns N' Roses VKEGNIO Roses Tank Top Women Amazon โ†— Cool Retro No Sleep Til Brooklyn, Old School Portable Stereo T-Shirt T-Shirt Cool Retro No Cool Retro No Sleep Til Brooklyn, Old School Portable Stereo T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Little Feat T-Shirt T-Shirt Little Feat Little Feat T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Pixies Monkey Grid T-Shirt - Black T-Shirt Pixies Pixies Monkey Grid T-Shirt - Black Amazon โ†— The Libertines Red Logo Sweatshirt Hoodie The Libertines The Libertines Red Logo Sweatshirt Amazon โ†— The Who Official Maximum R&B Tour T-Shirt T-Shirt The Who The Who Official Maximum R&B Tour T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Sex Pistols Official Union Jack Words T-Shirt T-Shirt Sex Pistols Sex Pistols Official Union Jack Words T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Womens Doobie Retro Hipster Design for Cool People V-Neck T-Shirt T-Shirt Womens Doobie Retro Womens Doobie Retro Hipster Design for Cool People V-Neck T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Pink Floyd Dark Side of The Moon Album Rock Music, T Shirt & Stickers Black T-Shirt Pink Floyd Pink Floyd Dark Side of The Moon Album Rock Music, T Shirt & Stickers Black Amazon โ†— The Sisters Of Mercy T-Shirt T-Shirt The Sisters Of Mercy The Sisters Of Mercy T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Dead Kennedys Classic Logo T-Shirt T-Shirt Dead Kennedys Dead Kennedys Classic Logo T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Jimi Hendrix 1960's Psychedelic Musical Icon Afro Purple Haze T-Shirt Tee T-Shirt Jimi Hendrix Jimi Hendrix 1960's Psychedelic Musical Icon Afro Purple Haze T-Shirt Tee Amazon โ†— God's Plan - Classic Hip Hop Rap Fan Gift T-Shirt T-Shirt God's Plan God's Plan - Classic Hip Hop Rap Fan Gift T-Shirt Amazon โ†— David Bowie - Rebel Rebel Lightning Lyric T-Shirt T-Shirt David Bowie David Bowie - Rebel Rebel Lightning Lyric T-Shirt Amazon โ†— GENESIS TRICK OF THE TAIL T-Shirt T-Shirt Genesis GENESIS TRICK OF THE TAIL T-Shirt Amazon โ†— INTO THE AM Graphic Tshirts for Men S - 4XL Cool Edgy Trippy Design Casual Tees Streetwear Skeleton Skull T-Shirt INTO THE AM Graphic Tshirts for Men S INTO THE AM Graphic Tshirts for Men S - 4XL Cool Edgy Trippy Design Casual Tees Streetwear Skeleton Skull Amazon โ†— TThe Doors L.A. Woman T-shirt T-Shirt The Doors TThe Doors L.A. Woman T-shirt Amazon โ†— Guitars Music Lover Funny Gift T-Shirt T-Shirt Guitars Music Lover Guitars Music Lover Funny Gift T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Black And White America CD CD Lenny Kravitz Black And White America CD Amazon โ†— CRIMSONS KING ARTWORK T-Shirt T-Shirt CRIMSONS KING ARTWORK CRIMSONS KING ARTWORK T-Shirt Amazon โ†— "Stayin' Alive" Vintage 1970s classic Distressed T-Shirt T-Shirt "Stayin' Alive" Vintage "Stayin' Alive" Vintage 1970s classic Distressed T-Shirt Amazon โ†— The Cure Rock Off Official Merchandise Boys Don't Cry Rocker Biker Fashion Men's Black Cotton Short Sleeve Crew T-Shirt T-Shirt The Cure The Cure Rock Off Official Merchandise Boys Don't Cry Rocker Biker Fashion Men's Black Cotton Short Sleeve Crew T-Shirt Amazon โ†— The B-52s - Album Cover T-Shirt T-Shirt The B-52s The B-52s - Album Cover T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Creedence Clearwater Revival Pendulum T-Shirt T-Shirt Creedence Clearwater Revival Creedence Clearwater Revival Pendulum T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Radiohead A Moon Shaped Pool T-Shirt T-Shirt Radiohead Radiohead A Moon Shaped Pool T-Shirt Amazon โ†— Grateful Dead T-Shirt T-Shirt Grateful Dead Grateful Dead T-Shirt Amazon โ†— John Lennon T Shirt Self Portrait Official Unisex Navy Blue T-Shirt John Lennon John Lennon T Shirt Self Portrait Official Unisex Navy Blue Amazon โ†— Bob Dylan Men's Highway 61 Revisited T-Shirt X-Large White T-Shirt Bob Dylan Bob Dylan Men's Highway 61 Revisited T-Shirt X-Large White Amazon โ†— Metallica - and Justice for All (Tracks) T Shirt T-Shirt Metallica Metallica - and Justice for All (Tracks) T Shirt Amazon โ†—

Sources & verification

Primary source
albumism.com
Secondary source
loudersound.com